Emerald Pages
◆
The Party of Lincoln? Why the Republican Party Never “Freed the Slaves”
Arnold Schwarzenegger's recent claim that the Republican Party "freed the slaves" ignores the self-emancipation of enslaved people and the party's century-long ideological realignment. Today's GOP bears no resemblance to its 1860s predecessor—and its policies and values align with white identity politics.
Arnold Schwarzenegger | Photo: The Jimmy Kimmel Show
Arnold Schwarzenegger recently told Jimmy Kimmel that he remains a Republican because he admires the party that freed the slaves. The remark, made during a November 12 interview, sparked immediate debate. But it rests on two profound historical errors: first, that the Republican Party freed the slaves at all; and second, that the modern GOP bears any ideological resemblance to its 19th-century namesake.
The historical record is clear. Enslaved Black Americans were the primary force in securing their own freedom. From the earliest days of the Civil War, hundreds of thousands fled Southern plantations, withdrawing their labor from the Confederate war effort in what W.E.B. Du Bois called a "general strike." Their mass exodus forced the Lincoln administration—which initially stated its only war aim was preserving the Union—to adopt emancipation as a military necessity.
Nearly 200,000 Black soldiers and sailors—most of whom had escaped slavery themselves—served in the Union Army and Navy. Their enlistment provided critical manpower at a turning point in the war, directly ensuring a Union victory that prevented the permanent division of the United States. The slaves, in other words, freed themselves by ensuring America would not become two separate countries.
The Party Realignment: A Century of Ideological Inversion
Even if one credits the 1860s Republican Party with political leadership, that party no longer exists. Historians and political scientists widely document a complete ideological and demographic realignment between the Civil War and the late 20th century. The 1860s GOP favored strong federal intervention to abolish slavery and establish civil rights. The 1860s Democratic Party championed states' rights and the preservation of slavery.
Over the following decades, the platforms inverted. Under Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal, Democrats embraced expansive federal programs while Republicans moved toward free-market conservatism. When Democratic presidents Kennedy and Johnson championed the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965, conservative white Southern voters left the Democratic Party. The Republican Party subsequently gained control of the South by campaigning on states' rights, law and order, and opposition to federal mandates—a strategy that drew many former Southern Democrats into the GOP.
- 1860s Republicans: Strong federal power to abolish slavery, establish civil rights, and fund national infrastructure; voter base concentrated in the North.
- 1860s Democrats: States' rights, limited federal power, preservation of slavery; primary support from the South.
- Modern GOP: Limited federal government, states' rights, social conservatism; voter base overwhelmingly white, with the South as a core region.
Schwarzenegger's claim relies on institutional continuity—the legal existence of the party name—rather than ideological continuity. He chooses to align himself with the party's 19th-century origins. But critics, including Kimmel, correctly note that the modern party's policies no longer represent those historical positions.
The Modern GOP and White Identity Politics
According to political scientists and exit polling data from the Pew Research Center, the Republican voter base is overwhelmingly white, and a majority of Black voters consistently support the Democratic Party. Since the 1960s "Southern Strategy," Republican campaigns have frequently appealed to white racial grievances to win elections.
Civil rights organizations, such as the NAACP and the Southern Poverty Law Center, have criticized prominent Republican figures for using rhetoric that echoes white nationalist talking points—such as the "Great Replacement" theory—and for failing to consistently denounce extremist groups. White supremacists predominantly support Republican candidates because of overlapping positions on immigration, nationalism, and opposition to diversity programs.
The policy impacts are measurable. Republican-backed policies—including restrictions on mail-in and early voting, opposition to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) programs, and limitations on how race and systemic racism are taught in public schools—disproportionately disenfranchise and marginalize Black Americans. When mainstream politicians champion the exact same legislative outcomes that white supremacists celebrate, the practical effect on marginalized groups is indistinguishable from overt hostility.
The Counterargument—and Its Limits
Republican leaders and conservative commentators dispute the claim that the party is hostile to Black Americans. They argue that conservative policies—lower taxes, deregulation, and school choice—create jobs and build wealth for Black families. They maintain that opposing race-based affirmative action and DEI programs promotes a "colorblind" society based on individual merit. Party leaders routinely state that white supremacy has no place in the Republican Party, pointing to the election of Black Republicans such as Senator Tim Scott and Representative Byron Donalds.
But the "guilt by association" fallacy cuts both ways. In a two-party system, every mainstream coalition shares specific policy positions with fringe extremists. The question is whether the overlap is incidental or constitutive. Civil rights advocates and critical race scholars argue that policies producing racially disparate outcomes—and sharing goals with white nationalists—function as systemic hostility regardless of stated intent. If a policy disproportionately harms Black and brown communities, the policy itself is hostile, regardless of how it is framed.
The historical truth is that enslaved people freed themselves, not the Republican Party. The political truth is that the modern GOP is a fundamentally different institution from its 1860s predecessor—one whose coalition, platform, and values are centered on white identity politics and hostile to the interests of Black Americans. Schwarzenegger's nostalgia for a party that no longer exists is not a defense of the current one. It is an evasion of what the current one has become.
No Ads. By Us. For Us.
This article was made possible by readers like you. We hope it inspired you to support Emerald Book, so we can continue producing content like this.
We will never show you ads, sell your data, or require a subscription to consume our content. Your gift helps us keep the truth accessible.
Click the Support button to give a gift of any amount today.
Thank you for making this work possible.