Emerald Icon
◆

Emerald Pages

◆
placeholder

Charlie Kirk (left), Stephen Miller (center left), Nick Fuentes (center right), Donald Trump (right) | Photo: Emerald Book Image

There is a comforting fiction America tells itself about bigotry: that it is a relic, a stain from a less enlightened past that fades with each generation, each law passed, each barrier broken. The election of a Black president was supposed to herald a post-racial dawn. The legalization of same-sex marriage was supposed to signal the end of a culture war. Each milestone was treated as proof of forward motion—evidence that the country was, however slowly, outgrowing its oldest hatreds. The story is reassuring because it casts prejudice as a temporary malfunction rather than a permanent feature—a problem to be solved rather than a condition to be managed.

But the persistence of bigotry in American life suggests something far less reassuring. It is not a temporary flaw waiting to be corrected. It is a foundational feature of American society, passed down through generations, reinforced by institutions, and sustained by a vast audience that actively wants it. The election of Donald Trump—a man who won 77,302,580 votes in 2024 despite 34 felony convictions, civil liability for sexual abuse, six corporate bankruptcies, and a documented history of racist rhetoric—was not an aberration. It was a reminder. And the reminder is not new. It is the same one James Baldwin delivered in 1963, the same one Dr. King offered from a Birmingham jail cell, the same one Derrick Bell spent his career documenting: America does not outgrow its hierarchies. It renovates them.

The United States was built alongside systems of racial slavery, Indigenous displacement, and selective immigration laws. These were not accidents of history; they were deliberate hierarchies that shaped American institutions from the very beginning. The Three-Fifths Compromise embedded racial hierarchy into the Constitution's arithmetic of power. The Naturalization Act of 1790 restricted citizenship to "free white persons." The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 wrote racial exclusion directly into federal immigration law. Jim Crow formalized segregation across the South for nearly a century. Redlining, enacted through the Home Owners' Loan Corporation in the 1930s, drew color-coded maps that determined which neighborhoods would receive federal mortgage backing—and which would be starved of it for generations.

The through-line is not a series of isolated moral failures. It is a consistent architecture of belonging and exclusion, maintained across centuries by every branch of government and every major institution. Racial hierarchy has existed without interruption for over 400 years, and it has never required a majority of Americans to actively hate anyone. It has only required a majority to accept the arrangement, or to look away.

A Built-In Audience

The uncomfortable truth is that bigotry endures because it is not a fringe behavior that society can easily isolate or shame. When millions of people share the same prejudices, it becomes a mainstream community norm with its own social safety net, workplaces, neighborhoods, and political power. Politicians, media networks, and online platforms push bigoted narratives because there is a massive, reliable audience eager to consume, validate, and vote for them. Supply follows demand.

This is the part the progress narrative cannot account for. If bigotry were simply a misunderstanding or a lack of information, it would evaporate under the weight of education and exposure. But it does not, because it is not a knowledge gap. It is a preference—a preference for a society arranged in a particular hierarchy, and a willingness to overlook nearly anything in a leader who promises to preserve it. The 77 million votes are not a mystery to be explained away by economic anxiety or media fragmentation. They are a market signal. There is demand for this product, and the product keeps selling.

  • Roughly a third of eligible adults did not vote in 2024, meaning the 77 million who backed Trump represent only a portion of the electorate—yet even that fraction constitutes tens of millions of Americans holding or excusing prejudiced views.
  • Social media algorithms and partisan media outlets reward outrage, fear, and us-versus-them narratives with clicks and ad revenue, creating a financial ecosystem where bigoted content is amplified rather than penalized. The First Amendment, unlike many democracies' hate-speech laws, protects almost all of it unless it directly incites imminent lawless action.
  • When pollsters ask about racial attitudes, social desirability bias inflates tolerance: people learn what is acceptable to say out loud, not necessarily what they believe in private. The quietness of prejudice is routinely mistaken for its disappearance.

This ecosystem has its figureheads, arranged like a ladder. Donald Trump operates at the widest scale, uniting tens of millions behind nationalist and anti-immigrant themes. Stephen Miller—appointed White House chief of staff in November 2026—translates that rhetoric into federal policy, giving institutional form to cultural grievance. Charlie Kirk, before his death in September 2025, built Turning Point USA into a campus network that mobilized young conservatives around anti-diversity and Christian-nationalist messaging. Nick Fuentes broadcasts explicit white nationalism to an audience that, by design, is smaller and more radical—but still large enough to be monetizable. Together they form a tiered pipeline: mainstream rallies, policy memos, campus debates, unfiltered livestreams. People can engage at whatever level of explicitness matches their own views while remaining part of the same broader cultural current. Even when these factions clash over tactics, they draw from the same reservoir.

The Myth of Inevitable Progress

Historians use the term "Whig history" to describe the false assumption that human society is on an inevitable, upward march toward greater freedom and enlightenment. In reality, history moves in waves of expansion and contraction. Every period of civil rights advancement—Reconstruction, the 1960s Civil Rights Movement—has been systematically followed by fierce political, legal, and cultural backlash aimed at rolling back those gains.

Reconstruction is the clearest case. The Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments—abolishing slavery, guaranteeing equal protection, and protecting voting rights—were ratified within five years. Then came the Compromise of 1877, the withdrawal of federal troops from the South, and the rise of Black Codes, poll taxes, literacy tests, and the Ku Klux Klan. Within a generation, the legal architecture of racial equality had been dismantled and replaced with Jim Crow. The same pattern repeated after the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965: within a decade, the Southern Strategy, "law and order" politics, and the War on Drugs had begun to resegregate schools, gut voting protections, and fill prisons with Black and brown Americans.

When overt bigotry becomes socially unacceptable or illegal, it does not vanish. It adapts. Scholars like Michelle Alexander and Derrick Bell argue that whenever overt systems of subjugation are dismantled, new, legally acceptable mechanisms—mass incarceration, voter suppression, school resegregation—emerge to preserve the same racial outcomes. The racial wealth gap in the United States remains nearly as wide today as it was in the 1960s—the median white household holds roughly six times the wealth of the median Black household—demonstrating that legal changes alone have not undone the material accumulation of generational advantage.

The Illusion of the Post-Racial Era

The period between Barack Obama's 2008 election and Donald Trump's 2016 victory offers a clear case study in how milestones become mirages. Many observers treated the election of the nation's first Black president as proof that America had entered a post-racial era. Because overt, socially acceptable racism had declined in mainstream public spaces, people who did not directly experience prejudice mistook its quietness for its disappearance. Meanwhile, significant portions of the electorate felt culturally displaced and resentful of rapid demographic shifts—resentments that eventually found a champion.

Political scientists describe charismatic strongman figures as offering a permission structure—by breaking taboos themselves, these leaders signal to followers that their private resentments are legitimate, patriotic, and safe to express openly again. The dynamics surrounding Trump echo recurring chapters in American history: post-Reconstruction America, the populist movements of the 1920s and 1930s, and George Wallace's campaigns, which used coded language around "law and order" to channel white backlash into national political power. Van Jones called the 2016 result a "whitelash." He was describing a recurrence, not an invention.

Why Modernity Will Not Cure Bigotry

The belief that education, technology, and economic development naturally make societies more tolerant is one of the core assumptions of Enlightenment thinking. It defies reality. Technology amplifies rather than cures—modern communication has repeatedly been used to spread conspiracy theories, reinforce echo chambers, and organize hate faster and wider than ever before. Higher education does not automatically produce empathy; throughout the 19th and 20th centuries, educated elites used modern "science" such as eugenics and scientific racism to give centuries-old prejudices an updated, intellectual justification. The printing press did not end sectarian violence. Radio did not end fascism. Social media has not ended racism.

Rapid industrialization, globalization, and automation constantly disrupt traditional ways of life. Rather than making people more cosmopolitan, economic displacement frequently triggers nostalgia and scapegoating against immigrants, minorities, and outsiders. Modern societies replace overt, personal violence with impersonal systems—housing algorithms, lending models, policing data, and zoning laws can perpetuate centuries-old hierarchies quietly, without anyone needing to use a slur or hold conscious hatred. Zygmunt Bauman's study of the Holocaust made the point starkly: modernity did not prevent atrocity; it industrialized it. Bureaucracy, efficiency, and record-keeping made mass harm possible at a scale no mob could achieve.

The sticky quality of bigotry is not a failure of modernity. It is one of modernity's products. Every new tool that connects people also connects prejudice; every new institution that claims neutrality also inherits the biases of the society that built it.

Why The Cycle Continues

Even after Democrats swept the November 2026 midterm elections—winning back control of both the House and Senate and flipping major statehouses—those millions of voters did not vanish overnight. Elections measure turnout and frustration, not moral transformation. A voter who sits out a midterm or temporarily crosses party lines out of frustration with the party in power has not necessarily abandoned underlying prejudices. The bigotry is still there, waiting.

As long as that massive audience remains intact, it will continue to wait for the next leader, movement, or cultural opening to reassert itself. Bigotry will never lack customers, voters, or defenders. Rather than being a temporary problem waiting to be solved, this built-in audience ensures that bigotry remains a constant, recurring force in society that people must reckon with rather than expect to vanish.

The realistic goal for a diverse democracy is not achieving a utopia free of human bias, but building strong laws, norms, and institutions that prevent individual bigotry from turning into systemic harm—and then never forgetting that the people who would tear those institutions down never actually left. Containment, not eradication, may be the only honest aspiration—because a nation built on hierarchy cannot legislate away the prejudices that sustain it. But it can refuse to forget the millions who carry them, and it can stay watchful for the moment they decide to act again.

No Ads. By Us. For Us.

This article was made possible by readers like you. We hope it inspired you to support Emerald Book, so we can continue producing content like this.

We will never show you ads, sell your data, or require a subscription to consume our content. Your gift helps us keep the truth accessible.

Click the Support button to give a gift of any amount today.

Thank you for making this work possible.

◆

Emerald Pages is a publication of
Emerald Book, Inc.

Follow us
Share
Scroll to Top